Wednesday, December 03, 2008

What On Earth Are We Doing?

American Christianity has turned Paul's admonition on its head.
Paul said,
"And do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind, that you may prove what is that good and acceptable and perfect will of God." (Ro 12:2).

We've changed it to
"And be conformed to the world, just make sure it has a veneer of Christianity so that we can claim we're only trying to reach the lost."

Exhibit A.

Is this church or a concert?

Is this a concert or church?

I'm really confused why the American Christian church has decided that worshiping God should look like the world's worship of its idols. I've heard all the excuses:
-I can't worship doing all that old fashioned stuff.
-We want to be relevant!
-People won't come to church unless we make it entertaining.
-Making Sunday service shallow and entertaining is the only way to be evangelical (i.e., it will draw the "unchurched").

Since when is worship about making sure we are satisfied? Since when did worship stop being about assenting to God's glory, and ascribing Him worth (which is the root of worship)? Since when did worship become nothing more than a vehicle for getting people to come in the door? Since when did we decide that church should be, "entertaining, attractive, not judgmental, and not invasive"? Since when did worship shift from God-centered to man-centered?


Exhibit B.


So we have Christian My Little Ponies. Is that so bad? I suppose you could make an argument that this is a harmless way to indulge in Western culture's obsession with providing our children endless forms and ammounts of entertainment. Heaven forbid they use their imaginations, much less in this case learn that Christianity is slightly more than pithy catchwords and jargon slapped onto the sides of rubber horses. Nevermind the fact that My Little Pony is fully pagan:


But then we have exhibit C.



Really? Really?!?!!!?!!? Is this where we are?

According to the manufacturer,
"Finally, a fasion doll you can feel good about giving your child or grandchild! God's Girlz are modest [if grammatically challenged -ed.], yet fashionable, and with meaningful content to encourage thoughtful play. Each 12" doll is fully posable and fitted with the latest fasion styles."

Let's look at a little Scripture:
"You shall not make for yourself a carved image—any likeness of anything that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth; you shall not bow down to them nor serve them. For I, the Lord your God, am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children to the third and fourth generations of those who hate Me, but showing mercy to thousands, to those who love Me and keep My commandments.
Ex 20:4-6."
Recognize it? Yeah, that's Commandment #2.
A lot of people are going to say, "Wait, that's the Old Testament. We're not under the Old Testament, so we can make carved images (dolls) if we want. Besides, we aren't making them to be worshipped."
Jesus said, "
But if you want to enter into life, keep the commandments.” (Mt 19:17).
As far as worshipping, what is the purpose of this doll? I would argue
that it teaches little girls how they are "supposed" to look. This doll represents what the world (and in this case American Christian culture) thinks women should look like, what little girls should emmulate. That is worship. That is the "thoughtful play" these dolls actually will encourage.

Is there a qualitative difference between these two? Be honest.


One is supposed to have "meaningful content" while the other is said to "sexualize young girls." I can't figure out which is which.

We can argue over whether it is appropriate to let little girls play with fashion dolls, but let's quit adding a Christian facade to secular culture - secular culture that we Christians are blaming for the moral degradation of morality in said culture. It's kind of like someone who wallows around in a pig's mud pit and argues, "But at least I'm not a pig!"
On the manufacturer's website, they encourage retailers to carry their stuff because, "Christian/Inspirational products account for over $4 billion in retail sales annually."

Truly we are of the world, but not in it. Most of us spend our entire life immersed in this pseudo-Christian subculture, thinking we are glorifying God because we are participating in that subculture. We would never be caught in a Nickelback concert, but we have no problem going to a Sunday service that is indistinguishable from one. We would never buy our child a Bratz doll, but we "feel good about" giving her a doll that looks just like one. We don't want our children playing with "pagan" My Little Ponies, but we will buy them "Praise Ponies" that are exactly the same, but for the little symbols on thier haunches.






7 comments:

beula the music geek said...

Oh man. The concert similarities are what got me - oh man, oh man. I know we've talked about this before, but DOLLS and PONIES?? You have GOT to be kidding, but I see you aren't. Sometimes I really hate what 'Christianity' has become. Okay, so most of the time. I'm frustrated, but not surprized, with the depth of immorality hidden within - well, not so hidden I guess.

simplykersh said...

Robert, Robert, the difference between the dolls is easy to see. the 'christian' one is Anglo-saxon. And judging by the tiara and clothing styles- upper middle class. the perfect 'christian' girl. (note: sarcasm).

In partial defense of contemporary music in churches (it does go too far sometimes) Didn't the Temple have around 1000 musicians praising God? I would assume that they sang Psalms or stuff written by the Levites. Aren't most hymns based on old bar songs or 'common songs' Just a thought.

I do agree that too often we try to be exactly like the world...just less swearing and more smugness. Can you imagine Christian cookbooks, action figures, Testa-mints and other christian junk.

I think that by looking and acting like the world we negate the impact of witnessing. "Why be a Christian when they are just like me."

psychobob said...

"In partial defense of contemporary music..."
Its really more the whole organization of the church, not just the music. ;-)

simplykersh said...

What would be a solution? What is the disease? What is in your post are all bad symptoms or are they the disease?

psychobob said...

From my perspective it is a systematic misunderstanding of God, and what worship of Him is. Worship is not "experiencing God" at church (although I definately think we do), but a lot of "praise" music focuses on our interaction with God ("I love you" "I'll follow you" "I want to know you more" etc.)
Worship is also not entertainment, not a means to "bring people in," but a lot of church services revolve around providing a good show for the people. Hence my pic showing one of the biggest churches in America, and the one below it that looks identical but is an actual concert.
How do we fix it? I'm not sure. I think we can start by going back to underlying themes of worship in the whole Bible, and what the early church thought was important. Things like Communion, worship, and the Word.
Worship needs to match the Bible's definition of worship, instead of our postmodern experience-driven model.
What about you?

Anonymous said...

Hey Bob,
i noticed your blogspot and was very encouraged to see your consideration of how worldly the people who claim to be of God have become in the face of commands (and actually promises) that we can be different. i have read other articles and such that address the same topic. There is a 14 page (16 with cover and back) PDF booklet that i think you would find very interesting. i don't know how to attach or if i can attach it to a comment on your blog. If you are interested let me know how and i will get it to you.

psychobob said...

Send it to psychobobicus@yahoo.com and I'll look at it.